A Jew is a Jew is a Jew.
At least that holds true to the
outside world. But within Judaism, there is a rich specter of individual choices
that one can make, while still retaining - and indeed enriching our religious lives.
I respect those that practice what they preach. I
reject those that, out of ignorance or arrogance, look down on others because
they don't follow the narrow path carved from rigid customs and dogmas.
I believe that Judaism allows rationalism and plurality
of opinions and interpretations. That's what the Mishnah and the Talmud are all
about. Within the philosophies and rituals of Orthodox, Conservative, Liberal,
Reform, and Reconstructionist, a Jew can find the road which most appeals to his
beliefs. We Jews have the right, even the obligation, to open our spiritual
selves to the possibility of enlightenment of our religious viewpoints. We
should not live as hypocrites. We should know who we are and why we are. We
should not allow ourselves to adhere - or pretend to adhere - to customs just
because "that's what my father did and his father before him."
Judaism is Torah. Judaism is Mitzvah. Judaism is
treating others as you would want others to treat you. Judaism is a belief in
one G-d. We have a rich tradition that can be traced over 5,000 years. We have
been feared and distrusted, enslaved and exploited, displaced and murdered, all
in the name of God and country. No one who is not Jewish can possibly understand
what a Jew feels in terms of insecurity because of our sufferings; in the worst
of times - and the best of times.
Is there any excuse therefore for a Jew to maltreat
another Jew? Do you really think that a person's Jewishness, or his/her
commitment to Jewish values, can be measured by whether or not he/she follows
Kashrut, or observes Rosh Hashanah one day instead of two, or permits women to
ascend the Bimah and enjoy equal rights - and obligations - as any man? Are
converts to Judaism, people who have consciously studied and chosen with their
minds and hearts to accept Jewish values and practices, to be considered as
second class Jews, and be barred from our holy halls?
We are a small people. We are but a tiny speck of sand
among billions and billions. Quantitatively, we are but a decimal point in the
population of the world. But what a point!
We have no Jews to lose! That has been the main
criteria on which B'nei Israel was founded and has existed throughout these last
thirteen years. We call ourselves Reform, but in reality, we are more
Conservative than Reform in the way we observe our traditions. What is a name?
We have become what our members are most comfortable with.
We are an open community. We welcome visitors from
other lands. People who come to our services feel good, afterwards. Our Onegs
which follow every Friday night service, are noted for their warmth and
camaraderie.
Why did we start B'nei Israel? Because we had to; if we
wanted to live as Jews.
So let us delight in our freedom to be who we are:
Jews, in a country with stands for freedom and tolerance. Halevai!
- Marvin Sossin
"B'nei Israel Bulletin, August 1995"
Back to top
Back to Home